Archive for November, 2009

If You Can Google it

Posted by doug On November - 27 - 2009ADD COMMENTS

3389581452 2a5b6a8ba0 m If You Can Google it

One of the people I follow on Twitter sent the following tweet;

 

“If you can google it, it shouldn’t be on a test.”

 

To which I simply replied;

 

“Nonsense”

 

What made me say that, apart from being in a bit of a grumpy mood that day?

 

Education is not about the learner cramming their head with facts, figures and information which they then regurgitate in a test or exam. That is a feature which marred the schooling of many during the latter years of the last century. There is far too much knowledge out there for it to fit meaningfully into a young adult’s brain.

 

As a middle-aged adult, I know that much of the ‘stuff’ we were taught in school has never been used, or hardly ever used, since. So what was the purpose of the teacher spending time teaching it? Surely that time could have been better spent teaching something else? It seems the only purpose for teaching some things was so that we could reiterate it in a test or examination.

 

21st Century learning, if I may use such a grandiose and overused phrase, is not about cramming a learner with facts and figures; 21st century learning is about using tools to find the answers or information you need. I will say now that those tools are not just technological tools; face-to-face meetings, conversations, dialogue, debates etc., are all included but the technological tools provide a modern and versatile way of accessing and using the information. One of the key technological tools is, of course, the internet search engine, such as Google.

 

It often appears that while learning in the 21st century is changing, our methods of assessment are changing only very slowly. Our assessments still seem to be dominated by tests and exams that are still wedged in old 20th century methods. Indeed, it might even be argued that education as a whole has been held back in its development by the need to produce good SAT and examination results.

 

So why did I object to the tweet? I did so because it seems to me that the message is basically saying that learners should not use an internet search engine to help them find their answer to a problem. I also object because it seems to represent an old view of testing.

 

Obviously, the tweet was presented without any context and this is often a problem with Twitter. The same tweet could be interpreted differently by other people. I do apologise to the person who made the original statement if there has been any misunderstanding on my part.

(image by dullhunk)

 If You Can Google it

Possibly Related Posts:


Post to Twitter Post to Digg Post to Ping.fm Post to StumbleUpon

Do we really need a New OS?

Posted by doug On November - 20 - 2009ADD COMMENTS

 

I am currently preparing a short post on interoperability but decided to make a diversion today following the release of details regarding Google’s new operating system, Chrome OS.

Basically, the question in the title says it all, do we need a new OS? We already have Windows (in its various flavours) which is widely used in schools across the country. We also have MAC OS, which has recently been updated and there are the various distibutions of Linux. Add to these the multitude of operating systems for mobile phones and handheld devices (iphone, Windows Mobile, Android…) and you can see that there are a whole welter of operating systems out there being used and most are incompatible with each other. So do we really need another OS?

 

 Do we really need a New OS?

Possibly Related Posts:


Post to Twitter Post to Digg Post to Ping.fm Post to StumbleUpon

ICT training sessions

Posted by doug On November - 15 - 2009ADD COMMENTS

Attic studio: Enough Computing Power?

Not too long ago I led two ICT training sessions which have been very similar in outcome even though the schools were very different.

One school was using Mac notebooks, whereas the other was using Windows machines. The Mac school had been unable to make best use of the software they were attempting to use because the software was essentially Html and flash based and they were trying to run the software on an old version of Internet Explorer. The second school had been unable to make best use of their software because it had not been installed properly on their network, so would not run properly (if at all) and they had not had effective training on it.

At the Mac school, I was able to demonstrate the software using Safari instead of Internet Explorer. Mac fans will say that this was a simple and obvious move to make and may be wondering why it had not already been done. What we have to keep in mind is that in a small school such as this, staff simply do not have the time to explore all ICT possibilities, especially when trying to solve technical issues. The software had previously run OK in IE but new developments and innovations in the software had left IE behind. The staff simply felt that the software was somehow incompatible with their system or required technical troubleshooting which they were unable to provide. The staff wanted to focus upon delivering teaching to their pupils rather than incur costs and time repairing the software. Consequently, they either ignored the software or only made use of those parts that did still seem to work.
This school is very far from being unique in seeing staff become frustrated or jaded by ICT technical issues. It would be true to say that there should be a technician on hand to prevent or sort out such technical issues so that teachers can continue to deliver education to the pupils. However, it it very much the case that primary schools have very inadequate technical support. Having a technician visit half a day each fortnight is quite a common pattern and it is certainly far from adequate in maintaining modern educational systems. Often, problems have to be reported in incident books, which will be read by the technician upon arival, he then has to decide a priority for the problems and try to implement a fix in the short time available. Sometimes telephone support is also available but this may sometimes mean a staff member taking the time to make the call and implement a fix (where possible)by sacrificing time which may better be spent elsewhere.

By showing this school how the software worked effectively on Safari, the school felt the software had been given a ‘new lease of life’ and that they were able to make much more use of it in their teaching. I was also able to show them many aspects of the software which they were unaware existed, simply because they had not been able to use the software.

In the second school, there was an element of frustration because the software had not initially been installed correctly on their network. This sort of problem should be entirely unnecessary but does still occur more often than it should. The problem had been rectified (almost) but the school staff had missed out on being able to use the software to support a number of teaching opportunities. They had also missed out on an effective training session because the system was not working properly.

I say the installation had been ‘almost’ rectified because we discovered that one staff member login did not allow proper access to the software. This was due to incorrect addressing of the program. Once I had spotted this, a quick and easy fix allowed the whole software to work effectively for this member of staff.

With the fix in place, I was able to train the staff on the software and was able to cover much of the ground that should have been covered in the original training session. Again, in this school, the staff felt that the software had been given a new ‘lease of life’ and that they were now better able to make use of it in their teaching.

I guess, in a small way, I may be blowing my own trumpet here in saying that I was able to renew these schools interest and usage of the software on their system. Yet, I feel that this is one of the most rewarding aspects of my training role; seeing staff enthused (or re-enthused) about using ICT or a particular piece of software or hardware.

 ICT training sessions

Possibly Related Posts:


Post to Twitter Post to Digg Post to Ping.fm Post to StumbleUpon